Billy Baker Sentenced To 55 Years In Prison For Murder SD Grad

Baker was sentenced on Tuesday in Dearborn County Court.

William "Billy" Baker. Photo by the Dearborn County Sheriff's Office. 

(Lawrenceburg, Ind.) – A Dillsboro man has received a lengthy prison sentence for the murder of an 18 year old South Dearborn High School graduate. 

William “Billy” Baker, 48, was sentenced on Tuesday in Dearborn County Court to 55 years behind bars for the shooting death of Paycin Kritlow during a graduation party at a home on Prosperity Ridge Road on July 19, 2020. 

Baker's sentencing comes after pleading guilty to Murder in June of this year. 

"There's no adequate sentence for this senseless killing," said Prosecutor Lynn Deddens. "The legislature has set up an advisory sentence for murder of 55 years. I can think of no one more deserving than William Baker. What should have been a day of celebration because of graduating from high school, is now a devastating memory to Paycin's family and friends." 

The sentence for murder is typically between 45 and 65 years. Because of Baker's limited criminal history, the defense was pushing for 45 years - but after a day and a half of evidence the advisory sentence of 55 years was decided on. 

According to court documents, Baker told investigators at the time of his arrest that a teenage family member told him she had been raped and that the person who did it was at the party. Baker proceeded to his house, retrieved a .30-06 rifle, and went to he shed, which was lit – so he could see through the scope.

A shot was fired, striking Kritlow.

Police interviewed the teen who Baker believed had been raped. The teen told police that at no time did she say she had been sexually assaulted and was unaware of any other person present at the party who made any such statements.

Baker gave a video confession to investigators the day after the incident, and made some "pretty damning statements" according to Prosecutor Deddens. 

He is credited with 614 days of time served. 

RELATED STORIES

Dillsboro Man Facing Murder Charge After Shooting Death Of SD Grad

18-Year-Old Killed In Dillsboro Shooting

More from Local News

Events

Rising Sun Municipal Utilities Planned Outage

A planned outage in Rising Sun originally set for Wednesday November 25th has been moved up a day to Tuesday November 24th.

Madison Man Arrested for Possession of Child Sexual Abuse Material

Brian Shockey was placed under arrest on 11/16/2026.

High School Hoops Scores - November 13-14, 2026

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Two Local High School Football Teams Advance to Semi-State

The East Central Trojans will play on Friday and the Milan Indians will play on Saturday.

South Dearborn Cheer is National Bound

The squad will compete at ESPN Wide World of Sports in January.

On Air

Eagle Country 99.3 playing
Megan Moroney and Kenny Chesney - You Had to Be There

T. Graham Brown I Tell It Like It Used to Be 12:23
Brad Paisley Then 12:19
Chris Stapleton Starting Over 12:15
Keith Urban Keith Urban - Little Bit of Everything - Eagle Only 12:08