Simpson Detective, Former Local Deputy Dies

Philip Vannatter testifies during the O.J.

Simpson murder trial in 1994.

Associated Press

(Lawrenceburg, Ind.) – After Philip Vannatter investigated one of the most famous murder cases in modern history, he was looking for a change of pace.

 

Vannatter was tasked with the role of lead investigator in the 1994 slayings of Nicole Brown Simpson and Ronald Goldman. Former football star O.J. Simpson would be charged with their murders, but was later acquitted following a lengthy trial.

 

The 28-year veteran of the Los Angeles Police Department died Friday in Santa Clarita, California at age 70. Family members told the Associated Press that Vannatter had complications with cancer.

 

After working alongside fellow detective Mark Fuhrman on the Simpson trial for over a year, Vannatter retired from the LAPD and moved to southeast Indiana.

 

He ran for sheriff in Switzerland County in 2002, but lost to Nathan Hughes. The former big city detective became chief deputy of the Dearborn County Sheriff’s Department from 2004 until 2007 under then sheriff Dave Lusby.

 

“He was a super human being, a gentle giant. We’ll miss him very much,” Lusby said Monday after learning of Vannatter’s death.

 

The O.J. Simpson murder case was not Vannatter’s only well-known case. In 1977, he also investigated and arrested film director Roman Polanski on charges that he drugged and had sex with a teen girl.

 

Vannatter’s funeral services are scheduled for Wednesday at Forest Lawn Memorial Park in Hollywood, California.

More from Local News

Events

Student Entrepreneurs Pitch Big Ideas at 2025 D.I.C.E. Challenge

Nine teams from Lawrenceburg High School, Oldenburg Academy, and South Ripley High School competed.

DCF Board Member Selects River Valley Resources for Proactive Grant

The organization’s 15 volunteer board members select a charitable organization to donate to each holiday season.

AAA Projects Record Travelers for 13-Day, Year-End Travel Period

The holiday travel period begins December 20.

East Central, Lawrenceburg Stars Named EIAC Soccer MVPs

The 2025 EIAC Girls and Boys Soccer All-Conference Teams were released on Tuesday.

Local Sports Report - December 16, 2025

Report missing stats and scores to news@eaglecountryonline.com

Euson, Gilmour, Bowling, Ballart Named EIAC MVPs

The EIAC has unveiled its 2025 Football All-Conference Team.

On Air

Your Hometown Radio Station playing
Terri Clark - Girls Lie Too

Mark Chesnutt It's A Little Too Late 5:15
Toby Keith You Shouldn't Kiss Me Like This 5:11
kelsey Hart Fireworks 5:07
Lady A Long Stretch of Love 5:04